United Airlines vs. American Airlines

---

United Airlines vs. American Airlines: Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between United Airlines and American Airlines isn’t as simple as picking the cheaper ticket. Both are global aviation giants with massive route networks, loyalty programs, and co-branded credit cards. But depending on how you travel—domestically or internationally, casually or frequently—one airline may deliver far more value than the other.

This in-depth comparison breaks down routes, loyalty programs, fees, onboard experience, and credit cards to help you decide which airline fits your travel style best.

---

Route Networks and Global Reach

Result: Virtual Tie (With Slight Differences in Strength)

American Airlines Route Coverage

American Airlines operates one of the largest airline networks in the world, serving 350+ destinations across North America, South America, Europe, and Asia. As a core member of the Oneworld alliance, American flyers gain access to numerous partner airlines, expanding global connectivity even further.

American’s route map is especially strong for:

• Domestic U.S. travel
• Latin America
• Europe via Oneworld partners

United Airlines Route Coverage

United Airlines slightly edges ahead numerically, flying to 360+ destinations across nearly 75 countries. As a member of the Star Alliance, United benefits from partnerships with globally dominant carriers, making it a strong choice for international travelers.

United excels in:

• Asia-Pacific routes
• Europe
• Long-haul international connectivity

Bottom line:

American is often more convenient for U.S.-based flyers, while United has an edge for globe-trotters heading overseas.

---

Loyalty Programs: MileagePlus vs. AAdvantage

Winner: American Airlines AAdvantage

American Airlines AAdvantage Program

American’s loyalty program stands out because flying isn’t the only way to earn elite status. Members accumulate Loyalty Points through:

• Flights
• Credit card spending
• Shopping portals
• Dining programs

This flexibility makes elite status achievable even for travelers who don’t fly weekly.

Additionally, American miles generally retain stronger value due to more predictable award pricing, especially on partner airlines.

United MileagePlus Program

United’s MileagePlus program offers a cleaner upgrade system, but earning elite status still heavily depends on paid flights. The program relies on:

• Premier Qualifying Points (PQPs)
• Premier Qualifying Flights (PQFs)

Award pricing is fully dynamic, which means mileage costs for flights can fluctuate wildly—and often trend upward over time.

Bottom line:

American miles are typically worth more, and elite status is easier to earn without constant flying.

---

Extra Fees and Hidden Costs

Winner: United Airlines

United and American charge similar fees for bags and seat selection, but United pulls ahead in a few areas.

United Airlines Fees

• In-flight Wi-Fi for members starts at $8
• Pet-in-cabin fee: $150
• Mileage redemption option for Wi-Fi

American Airlines Fees

• Wi-Fi generally starts at $10
• Pet-in-cabin fee: $150
• Limited complimentary Wi-Fi via ads on select flights

Bottom line:

United offers slightly better value for connectivity and ancillary services.

---

In-Flight Experience and Comfort

Result: Tie

American Airlines Onboard Experience

American offers multiple cabin options, including:

• Economy
• Main Cabin Extra
• Premium Economy
• Business and Flagship First

Passengers receive complimentary snacks and soft drinks, while premium cabins enjoy meals and alcoholic beverages. Some aircraft still feature seatback screens, though many rely on personal devices for entertainment.

Main Cabin Extra seats provide extra legroom and complimentary alcohol for elite members—a perk United doesn’t fully match.

United Airlines Onboard Experience

United performs strongly in operational reliability and ranks higher in on-time performance. Cabin options include:

• Economy
• Premium Plus
• Polaris Business Class

Entertainment is usually streamed to personal devices, and Wi-Fi is available for a fee. United’s Polaris business class is widely regarded as one of the best long-haul business products among U.S. airlines.

Bottom line:

Neither airline clearly dominates—comfort and service quality are comparable overall.

---

Airline Credit Cards and Benefits

Winner: American Airlines

United Airlines Credit Cards

United offers multiple personal and business cards with perks such as:

• Free checked bags
• Priority boarding
• Lounge access (on premium cards)
• Limited ability to earn elite-qualifying credits

However, credit card spending alone cannot earn top-tier elite status.

American Airlines Credit Cards

American’s co-branded cards shine because they allow cardholders to:

• Earn Loyalty Points through spending
• Qualify for elite status without frequent flying
• Access Admirals Club lounges (premium cards)

For travelers who prefer earning status via everyday spending, American’s cards provide a clear advantage.

---

Final Verdict: Which Airline Is Better?

Choose American Airlines if:

• You primarily fly within the U.S.
• You want easier elite status through spending
• You value consistent award pricing
• You prefer a larger domestic network

Choose United Airlines if:

• You frequently travel internationally
• You want stronger global Star Alliance connectivity
• You care about slightly lower Wi-Fi costs
• You value Polaris business class for long-haul flights

Overall Winner: American Airlines

While United is an excellent airline—especially for international travel—American Airlines delivers better overall value through its loyalty program, credit card ecosystem, and ease of earning elite benefits.